Begging for Halloween Candy: One Awesome Solution

Talks and negotiations for candy and sweet treats in our house reached an all-time high in the weeks following the holidays and I grew weary of the asking, the begging and the whining.

One day when my son asked me for “Just one more gelt,” I realized I was sick of rationing. I was done.

I instituted a special Special Time session called “Candy Time.”

“Hey Joshua, let’s have some Special Time where all we do is eat candy! What do you say?”

“Yeah!” he replied, with total enthusiasm.

We bonded in our united sense of purpose as we pulled every treat we could find out of the cupboard: the marshmallows, fudge, cookies, chocolate chips, scary candy, sours and chews.

“Don’t forget the raisins Mom,” Joshua said, and only then did I realize just how much rationing I’d been doing!

Start the Clock

“Okay Josh, here’s the deal, I’m going to set the timer for five minutes and you can have as much of all this stuff as you want, OK?”

His eyes lit up and he started unwrapping and arranging as I set the timer.

As I intentionally delighted in all the sugary treats he was ingesting and made comments like, “That one looks so yummy,” and “Doesn’t that taste so good!?” I could see in his eyes how different an experience it was for him to enjoy his treats like this, instead of the tone i’d set where I was begrudging him his joy in the sweets.

“Do you want a bite, Mommy?” he offered.

“Sure,” I replied as I took a taste of the fudge, “Mmmm, that is tasty!”

After what seemed like forever, he asked me how much time he had left.

“About two minutes.”

He didn’t rush. He savoured every bite, and when the timer did go off he asked if he could eat the last few mini-marshmallows he had lined up. I agreed and we put everything away.

Now he asks for “Candy Time” about once a week. Sometimes he asks more frequently and I say, “Yes,” or “No.”

Interestingly, it doesn’t seem to be a problem on the days I do say “No.” And that’s when I hit my high.

-Sarah MacLaughlin is a Hand in Hand Instructor in Training who also blogs at

Messy Loud Real-Life ParentingFind our more about how Special Time can transform parenting struggles. Read this to see how Special Time Melts Away Morning Stress

Watch our free Special Time video series for a step-by-step guide to using Special Time and fun examples of what it can look like.

Now print your free Special Time guide and checklist, and don’t forget to let us know how it goes!

Share this post

Shopping Cart