Why Must My Kids Hit Each Other?

Michelle CarlsonHitting, it’s the worst! Especially to see your own children hit one another. My girls used to get physical the moment there was any sort of kerfuffle. The Old Me would threaten, “You hit your sister again and you won’t be able to go to the park later!” It worked in the very short term, but they always seemed to resort to hitting again. (If you are the one your child hits, see “When Your Toddler Hits You: A New Perspective.”)

So I took an online Parenting by Connection class called “Taming Sibling Rivalry.” It was life changing. I learned to set a limit without bribing, shaming, or threatening. I would remind the girls they were not allowed to hit one another and explain to them how sorry I was I didn’t get there in time to help.  Then I listened to the upsets and hurts they had with one another. I tried not to take sides and just remained calm finally knowing that it was their struggle to get through and not mine.

When the girls came together to “explain” each side of the story there were some common themes emerging. Firstly, there was a lot of miscommunication and hurt feelings that ended in physical hurt. Usually I was able to let the girls explain their side of the story without insulting each other ( I had to set a limit here too) and they were able to move on.

Just to have the space to explain themselves, to be heard, was enough to change the dynamic. I never made them apologize, although that had been my MO for years. So occasionally they would apologize to each other on their own. I thought this was great progress. Other times they acknowledged their wrong-doing in the incident, unprompted.

Over time my older daughter found more compassion for her sister and my younger daughter found her voice. The imbalance of power came back to the middle. One day, well after I had completed all the videos and homework from the class, I could hear them arguing. I did a “drive-by” down the hall very quietly. I heard my older daughter acquiesce to her sister, allowing her to have all the power, giving into her little sister’s request to be the “mom” in their imaginary play. This never happened! My eldest had always insisted on being the “boss,” the “mom,” the one in charge. But finally my younger daughter was able to ask for what she wanted and her older sister was relaxed and connected enough to allow her the power position in their play.

Not only are my daughters more relaxed and cooperative with one another, the whole family now shares more warmth and flexibility.

Michelle Carlson, Certified Parenting by Connection Instructor in Los Angeles

Get more ideas to soothe sibling rivalry in our free call From Hatred to Harmony: How Hand in Hand Changes Sibling Rivalry, this April. 

For more playful, practical parenting get our monthly newsletter. Sign up here!

In Stores August 23rd! Click to pre-order

Listen Coming Soon with Authors


4 thoughts on “Why Must My Kids Hit Each Other?”

    1. You are a loving mom to be looking for ways to help your kids get along better. I know I had many struggles with my own daughters. It broke my heart to see them engaged in tangles that ofter time ended in physical hurts. Over time using the HIH method I have helped them love each other on a deeper level. It wasn’t over night but it has worked wonders.

      The Taming Sibling Rivalry is a class you can take online. Here is a link to purchase it and review the coursework on your computer:


      Triplets must be really challenging I can only imagine. In the Sibling class Patty outlines some helpful tools like Special Time and Playlistening both of which may help with your kids.

      Sibling Rivalry. in my opinion is one of the most difficult things as a parent to witness. It can tear our hearts out to see our kids hurt one another emotionally and physically. Witnessing this can likely bring up our own childhood memories of struggles with our siblings if we had them. For only children they have a hard time imagining being cruel to a brother or sister because that is all they ever wanted. Nonetheless bringing up old unresolved feelings.

      Getting connected using the Hand In Hand tools is a great start in beginning to unknot the messiness of sibling rivalry.

      Much love,

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top